Valuation Coverage vs. Moving Insurance: Key Differences

When moving, protecting your belongings is crucial. You have two main options: valuation coverage and moving insurance. They differ in cost, coverage, and how claims are handled:

• Valuation Coverage: Offered by moving companies, it’s not actual insurance but a liability agreement. It includes:
  • Released Value Protection (free, $0.60 per pound per item).
  • Full Value Protection (costs ~1% of item value, covers repair, replacement, or cash settlement).
  • Limitations: Doesn’t cover self-packed items, perishable goods, or natural disasters.
• Moving Insurance: Purchased separately, it provides broader protection, including:
  • Coverage for theft, natural disasters, and self-packed items.
  • Policies like Comprehensive, Named Perils, or Total Loss Coverage.
  • Costs ~1–5% of item value, with deductibles ($250–$1,000).

Quick Comparison

Feature	Valuation Coverage	Moving Insurance
Provider	Moving company	Third-party insurer
Cost	Free or ~1% of value	1–5% of value
Coverage Limit	$0.60/lb (basic) or full value (premium)	Declared value
Deductible	None (basic); applies for premium	$250–$1,000
Natural Disasters	Not covered	Often covered
Self-packed Items	Limited or no coverage	Generally included
Claims Process	Through moving company	Through insurance provider

Key Takeaway

Choose valuation coverage for basic protection and moving insurance for comprehensive coverage, especially for long-distance moves or valuable items. Combining both can offer the best protection.

Why Is Valuation Coverage Not Included in the Cost of My Move

Understanding Valuation Coverage

Basic Concepts

Valuation coverage is a legal requirement under federal law (49 CFR Part 375) that defines the liability of your moving company. It determines the compensation you'll receive if your belongings are lost or damaged during the move, based on the mover's responsibility.

Below, we break down the two main types of valuation coverage that movers typically provide.

Coverage Types

Moving companies generally offer two options for valuation coverage:

Released Value Protection

• Included at no extra cost with your move
• Provides basic liability coverage of $0.60 per pound
• Example: If a 50-pound TV is damaged, you’d only receive $30 (50 lbs × $0.60)

Full Value Protection

• A premium option, costing about 1% of the declared value of your belongings
• Covers repair, replacement, or a cash settlement for lost or damaged items
• Example: For $50,000 worth of belongings, this would cost around $500

Coverage Type	Cost	Protection Level	Compensation Method
Released Value	Free	$0.60 per pound	Based on item weight
Full Value	~1% of value	Full replacement	Repair, replace, or cash payout

Coverage Limits

While valuation coverage provides a safety net, it has its limitations:

Items Not Covered

• Items you pack yourself (unless the mover is clearly at fault)
• Perishable goods
• Important documents or electronic data
• Cash and jewelry

Coverage Restrictions

• Claims must be filed within 9 months of delivery
• Doesn't cover pre-existing damage
• Excludes natural disasters or "acts of God"

It's important to weigh these limitations when deciding if valuation coverage alone is enough or if you need additional moving insurance for better peace of mind.

Understanding Moving Insurance

Basic Concepts

Moving insurance offers an extra layer of protection beyond the basic coverage provided by moving companies, known as valuation coverage. Unlike valuation coverage, moving insurance is purchased separately through licensed insurers. It typically includes premiums and deductibles based on the value of your belongings. Let’s take a closer look at the common types of moving insurance policies.

Insurance Policy Types

Here are the main types of moving insurance policies:

• Comprehensive Coverage: Covers most risks, including natural events and self-packed items, unless specifically excluded in the policy.
• Named Perils Coverage: Protects against specific risks like fire, theft, or accidents. While premiums are lower, deductibles tend to be higher.
• Total Loss Coverage: Provides payment only if all items in the shipment are lost.

What Insurance Covers

The coverage offered by moving insurance goes beyond what valuation coverage provides. It typically includes protection against natural disasters, theft during transit or storage, accidental damage, and losses involving self-packed or high-value items.

Some policies also offer additional options, such as coverage for temporary storage, matching sets or pairs, and specialized items like fine art. To ensure a smooth claims process, you’ll need an accurate inventory of your belongings and photos documenting their condition. Keep in mind that claim procedures and deadlines can vary depending on the policy.

When paired with valuation coverage, moving insurance helps address any gaps, offering more complete protection for your move.

sbb-itb-290b89d

Comparing Both Options

Side-by-Side Comparison

Here’s a quick breakdown of the differences between valuation coverage and moving insurance:

Feature	Valuation Coverage	Moving Insurance
Provider	Offered by the moving company	Provided by licensed third-party insurers
Cost Structure	Based on shipment weight	Based on the declared value
Coverage Limit	Around $0.60 per pound for Released Value Protection, or full value for comprehensive coverage	Matches the declared value
Deductible	None for Released Value; deductibles apply to Full Value Protection	Typically ranges from $250 to $1,000
Claims Process	Handled by the moving company	Managed by the insurance provider
Natural Disasters	Usually not included	Often covered under comprehensive policies
Self-packed Items	Limited or no coverage	Generally included
High-value Items	May have restrictions	Full coverage often available

These details make it easier to pick the type of protection that suits your move.

Coverage Providers

Valuation coverage is part of the service offered by movers, while moving insurance comes from independent insurers. This difference also impacts costs and how claims are handled.

Cost and Coverage Details

To recap, Released Value Protection covers items at about $0.60 per pound, while Full Value Protection costs roughly 1–2% of your shipment's total value. Moving insurance, on the other hand, typically costs 1–5% of the declared value, with deductibles ranging from $250 to $1,000. Claims for moving insurance are usually processed within 30 days.

Here’s a real-world example for a 5,000-pound shipment valued at $50,000:

• Released Value Protection: Maximum coverage of $3,000 (5,000 lbs × $0.60)
• Full Value Protection: Costs between $500 and $1,000
• Moving Insurance: Covers full replacement value for $500 to $2,500

For valuation coverage, claims must be filed with the moving company within nine months of delivery. Insurance claims, however, can often be submitted online with photos and detailed inventories.

Choosing the Right Option

When to Choose Valuation Coverage

Valuation coverage works best for:

• Everyday items with moderate value
• Local moves where risks are lower
• Items professionally packed by movers
• Situations where homeowner's or renter's insurance already provides some coverage

Full Value Protection is better suited for:

• Items with higher monetary or sentimental value
• Moves handled by reputable movers with a strong claims record
• Coverage managed directly by the moving company
• Those who prefer dealing with a single provider for claims and coverage

In some cases, broader insurance options may be necessary to address specific risks.

When to Choose Moving Insurance

Consider moving insurance when:

• Moving long distances or internationally
• Transporting valuable collections, antiques, or irreplaceable items
• Storing belongings during the move
• Relocating to areas prone to natural disasters

Key Decision Factors

To decide on the right protection, weigh these factors:

Factor	What to Consider
Move Distance	Longer moves increase the likelihood of damage, making insurance a safer choice.
Item Value	Pricier items require more robust coverage for peace of mind.
Packing Method	Self-packed belongings may need extra protection, as movers may not cover damages.
Timeline	Moves involving storage or extended transit require additional safeguards.
Budget	Weigh the cost of premiums against the potential risk of loss or damage.
Claims History	Look into the provider's track record for resolving claims quickly and fairly.

Other important factors include:

• Whether you prefer claims to be handled by the mover or an insurance company
• Any gaps in your current insurance policies
• Documentation requirements for claims
• How and when payments are made for coverage

Many people choose a combination of options to ensure thorough protection. For instance, pairing Released Value Protection with supplemental moving insurance can provide a customized solution that covers all bases.

Protection Best Practices

Item Documentation

Having detailed records of your belongings can make the claims process much easier if something gets damaged or lost. A well-documented inventory works hand-in-hand with your protection plan by offering clear proof when filing a claim.

Here’s how to document your items effectively:

• Photograph everything: Take clear pictures of each item, especially valuables or fragile pieces.
• Write detailed descriptions: Include information like the item's condition, brand, or any unique features.
• Make an inventory list: Note each item's value and organize it room by room.
• Pack carefully: Use proper packing materials for delicate items to minimize risk.
• Label boxes clearly: Indicate what’s inside and where it’s headed.
• Highlight special needs: Mark any boxes that require special handling.
• Record existing damage: Document any scratches, dents, or wear before the move.
• Back up your records: Save copies of everything in multiple places, like cloud storage and a physical folder.

Additional tips for thorough documentation:

• Snap close-up photos of expensive or fragile items.
• Record serial numbers and model details where applicable.
• Keep receipts for high-value belongings.
• Use both digital and printed copies of your inventory.
• Add date stamps to your photos and files for accuracy.
• Break down your inventory by room to stay organized.

Conclusion

Key Takeaways

Choosing between valuation coverage and moving insurance comes down to the specifics of your move. Valuation coverage, provided by moving companies, offers basic protection based on the weight or declared value of your items. Moving insurance, available through third-party providers, delivers more extensive protection.

Here’s a quick breakdown of the differences:

• Valuation coverage is included in your moving contract.
• Moving insurance requires purchasing a separate policy.
• They differ in coverage limits and how claims are handled.
• Costs vary depending on the option you choose.

How to Decide

When deciding between the two, think about:

• Value of Your Items: How much are your belongings worth?
• Distance of the Move: Is it a short move or long-distance?
• Risk Comfort: Are you okay with basic coverage, or do you want something more thorough?
• Budget: Weigh the cost of protection against its limitations.
• Timing: How much time do you have to arrange coverage?

If you're still unsure, it’s worth looking into services that can help you compare and decide.

MOD24 Moving Services

Need a little extra guidance? MOD24 can connect you with licensed, insured movers and help you enhance your protection plan with added perks. Their platform not only matches you with verified movers but also offers exclusive benefits to make your move smoother.

Here’s what MOD24 provides:

• A $100 TV insurance credit
• A $49 discount on your move
• One free month of storage
• A $200 discount for cross-country moves

MOD24’s strict verification process ensures you’re working with trusted movers who offer proper coverage and follow industry standards. This makes it easier to choose between valuation coverage and moving insurance while giving you peace of mind during your move.