Top 5 Metrics for Multi-Stop Route Performance

Want to improve your delivery routes? Start by tracking these 5 essential metrics:

1. Delivery Time Accuracy: Measures how often deliveries are on time. Aim for 95–98% accuracy to meet customer expectations and reduce delays.
2. Average Cost Per Delivery (CPD): Tracks all costs (fuel, labor, vehicle) per delivery. Lower costs by increasing route density and avoiding failed deliveries.
3. Distance Between Stops: Shorter, optimized distances reduce fuel usage and time. Use zone-based planning and real-time adjustments.
4. Service Duration: Time spent at each stop. Standardize processes and train drivers to stay on schedule.
5. Miles Per Gallon (MPG): Tracks fuel efficiency. Improve it with proper vehicle maintenance, better driver habits, and load management.

How They Work Together:
These metrics help cut costs, improve efficiency, and boost customer satisfaction. Use real-time data to analyze trends, adjust routes, and make smarter decisions.

Metric	Goal/Target	Key Benefit
Delivery Time Accuracy	95–98% accuracy	Better customer satisfaction
Average Cost Per Delivery	Lower CPD	Higher profitability
Distance Between Stops	Shorter distances	Reduced fuel and time
Service Duration	Minimized time	On-time schedules
Miles Per Gallon (MPG)	Higher efficiency	Lower fuel costs

Tracking these metrics ensures efficient, cost-effective, and reliable delivery operations.

Related video from YouTube

1. Delivery Time Accuracy

Delivery time accuracy is a critical metric in multi-stop route performance. It directly affects both customer satisfaction and operational expenses.

What’s the Ideal Range? Delivery time accuracy should ideally fall between 95–98%. If it drops below 90%, it often signals operational challenges that need attention.

Key Factors to Monitor

• On-Time Performance (OTP): Track arrival times for early, on-time, late, or failed delivery attempts.
• Operational Impact: Missing delivery windows can disrupt subsequent stops, leading to higher fuel consumption, overtime pay, and vehicle wear. These issues also negatively affect customer satisfaction.

Modern routing systems can achieve over 95% accuracy by factoring in real-time traffic, historical data, seasonal trends, and specific customer needs.

Practical Insights for Delivery Businesses

For industries like moving companies and delivery services, maintaining high accuracy is non-negotiable. Here's a breakdown of how delivery windows align with customer satisfaction:

Time Window Category	Target Accuracy	Customer Satisfaction Impact
2-hour window	90%+	Highest satisfaction
4-hour window	95%+	Good satisfaction
All-day window	98%+	Acceptable for some services

How to Improve Accuracy

Regularly analyze weekly delivery data to uncover patterns and address problem areas. Focus on:

• Congested zones that frequently cause delays
• Specific time periods prone to issues
• Driver performance trends
• Weather conditions affecting delivery timelines

Once you've addressed timing issues, take a closer look at cost efficiency to further streamline your operations.

2. Average Cost Per Delivery

Once you've nailed down on-time performance, the next step is to look at cost per delivery (CPD). Keeping an eye on CPD is essential for running profitable multi-stop delivery routes.

To calculate CPD, add up these key expenses:

• Direct Labor: Includes driver wages and benefits.
• Fuel: Covers variable fuel costs.
• Vehicle Costs: Includes maintenance, depreciation, and insurance.
• Overhead: Administrative costs, routing software expenses, and customer service operations.

Industry Benchmarks by Vehicle Type

The type of vehicle you use plays a big role in costs and capacity. Comparing your CPD with industry benchmarks for similar vehicles can help you spot opportunities to improve.

Strategies to Lower CPD

Want to cut down your CPD? Here are some practical approaches:

• Increase Route Density: Add more stops per route to maximize efficiency.
• Flexible Time Windows: Allow for more flexibility in delivery windows to simplify route planning.
• Choose the Right Vehicle: Match the vehicle size to the load requirements to avoid unnecessary costs.

Watch Out for Hidden Costs

Some factors might quietly drive up your CPD if you're not careful. Keep an eye on:

• Failed Deliveries: Missed delivery attempts can waste time and resources.
• Idle Time: Excessive idling burns fuel and increases costs.
• Peak Traffic Hours: Deliveries during high-traffic times can lead to delays and higher expenses.

Setting up a regular review process to monitor these areas will help you stay on top of trends and tweak your strategies as needed. This way, you can keep your delivery operations running as cost-efficiently as possible.

sbb-itb-290b89d

3. Distance Between Stops

Knowing the distance between stops is essential for improving route efficiency and cutting down unnecessary travel.

What Affects Stop Distance?

Several elements play a role in determining the best distance between stops:

• Urban vs. Rural Areas: Urban routes have stops closer together due to higher delivery density, while rural routes typically involve longer distances between stops.
• Type of Service: Local deliveries and long-haul shipments require different spacing approaches.
• Population Density: Areas with higher population density naturally lead to more clustered stops.
• Traffic Timing: Traffic conditions at different times of the day can change the ideal spacing of stops.

How to Measure Average Distance

To calculate average stop distance, focus on these key metrics:

• Total Route Distance (in miles): The total length of the route.
• Number of Stops: The total number of delivery points served.
• Dead Miles: Distance traveled without making deliveries.
• Route Density Score: The number of stops per mile, which reflects route efficiency.

Ways to Improve Stop Distance

Reducing unnecessary mileage can be achieved with these strategies:

• Zone-Based Delivery Planning
  Group deliveries into geographic zones to keep stops closer together and reduce travel time.
• Real-Time Route Adjustments
  Use live data on traffic, weather, and last-minute orders to make on-the-spot route changes.
• Efficient Stop Sequencing
  Arrange stops to avoid backtracking while considering time windows, vehicle load, and delivery priorities.

Practical Tips for Better Routes

• Regular Route Audits: Periodically review routes to identify areas for improvement.
• Adapt for Seasons: Adjust routes to accommodate seasonal changes in traffic and weather.
• Cluster Deliveries: Schedule deliveries in the same area for the same day to save time.
• Plan Stops Strategically: Consider building layouts and access points when deciding stop order.

Fine-tuning the distance between stops is a critical step in achieving greater delivery efficiency.

4. Service Duration

Service duration refers to the time drivers spend at each stop. It plays a key role in keeping schedules on track and improving route efficiency. Here's how it works and ways to manage it effectively.

This metric includes arrival time, unloading, documentation, and any extra time needed for special handling. The time required can vary widely depending on the type of stop:

• Residential stops: Typically 3–5 minutes.
• Commercial stops: Usually 5–8 minutes.
• Large facilities: Around 10–15 minutes.
• High-security locations: Often 15–20 minutes.

The type of package also affects service time. For example, standard packages take 2–4 minutes, while heavy items can require 5–10 minutes. Extra packages add 1–2 minutes each, and special handling may take an additional 5–15 minutes.

To improve efficiency, consider these strategies: pre-sort packages, prepare documentation ahead of time, use mobile scanning tools, and plan delivery windows to avoid peak facility hours.

Some delays are preventable, such as incorrect package sorting, missing paperwork, unclear delivery instructions, or poor parking choices. However, external factors like security checks, customer availability, restricted facility access, and bad weather can also slow things down.

To fine-tune service duration, focus on these key practices:

• Set realistic time windows for stops.
• Compare actual service times to planned ones to spot patterns.
• Standardize delivery procedures.
• Train drivers on efficient practices.
• Use digital proof of delivery to speed up documentation.

Keeping service duration in check not only helps stick to schedules but also builds trust with customers by ensuring reliable and consistent deliveries.

5. Miles Per Gallon

Miles per gallon (MPG) measures how efficiently vehicles use fuel on multi-stop routes. It's a key metric for managing costs, vehicle performance, and fuel usage. Together with delivery time and cost metrics, MPG offers a fuller picture of route efficiency.

Fuel efficiency varies by vehicle type. Box trucks, cargo vans, sprinter vans, and last-mile delivery vehicles all have different MPG ranges due to their design and the weight they carry.

Route conditions also impact MPG. Urban routes with frequent stops tend to consume more fuel because of constant acceleration, braking, and idling. In contrast, highway routes usually result in better fuel efficiency.

To improve MPG, focus on these areas:

• Vehicle Maintenance
  Keep tires properly inflated, change oil on schedule, replace air filters, and run regular engine diagnostics to maintain fuel efficiency.
• Driver Behavior
  Train drivers to maintain steady speeds, avoid rapid acceleration, and minimize idle time. These habits can significantly improve fuel performance.
• Load Management
  Distribute cargo evenly and avoid carrying unnecessary weight. Proper load management helps vehicles run more efficiently.
• Data Tracking
  Use telematics to monitor fuel consumption in real time. Analyzing this data can reveal patterns and areas for improvement.

Boosting MPG not only reduces fuel costs but also supports efforts to lower cost-per-delivery (CPD).

Conclusion

The five metrics we covered - delivery time accuracy, average cost per delivery, distance between stops, service duration, and miles per gallon - work together to improve multi-stop route performance. When analyzed as a group, they provide a full picture of how effectively your operations are running.

How They Work Together

Improving fuel efficiency (miles per gallon) through better route planning can cut down stop distances and reduce delivery costs. At the same time, fine-tuning service duration ensures deliveries stay on schedule.

Balancing Costs and Quality

You can lower operational costs without sacrificing service quality by focusing on:

• Keeping delivery windows consistent while maximizing fuel efficiency
• Managing time spent at each stop to maintain high service standards
• Planning routes that reduce unnecessary mileage without disrupting schedules

Using Data to Make Smarter Choices

Real-time data plays a big role in enhancing efficiency. Tracking these metrics allows fleet managers to:

• Spot trends in service duration that might impact route performance
• Adjust schedules based on actual travel and stop times
• Monitor fuel usage to assign vehicles more efficiently
• Calculate delivery costs with all operational factors in mind

Why It Matters Long-Term

Ongoing monitoring of these metrics leads to steady improvements over time. Treating them as interconnected pieces of the puzzle helps you refine operations while keeping service quality intact.